Education: Separate Or Mixed?

Feb 27, 2012 By Stephen, 11

Now let’s think for a minute here if this class were cut in half. Which half would you be on? Well, it’d be boys and girls, of course! What do you think the environment of the classroom would be like? Here’s some research that I found on this subject.

Supporters say splitting students by gender minimizes distractions

I believe this is true because if you are a girl, and you like talking about make-up or whatever, but all you hear is boys talking about sports, then you feel weird. But if you are in a class with all girls, then you can talk about makeup all you want. And Vice-Versa. Also girls think that boys are a nuisance in class, because they can be really distracting when they’re off task, like you! (Point to a boy who’s not really listening) Exactly! On the other side of the coin though, boys like being on their own, they say, because girls don’t appreciate their jokes and think boys are too messy and are also scared of snakes, well, most girls at least. Young males thrive on competition and confrontation, while young females require a more nurturing and cooperative learning environment. “When most young boys are exposed to threat and confrontation, their senses sharpen, and they feel a thrill,” Hankins teachers in Theodore, AL. were directed to create “competitive, high-energy” classrooms for boys and “cooperative, quiet” classrooms for girls.

Guys think differently than Girls

I believe this is also true because boy’s nervous systems are wired differently than girls. Boys, you need to engage their energy. So instead of them raising their hands, they literally stand up. Or ball tosses during a discussion. For girls however, you need to do a lot of meeting in circles to talk about their personal lives. For girls, David Chadwell prescribes focus on “the connections girls have (a) with the content (b) with each other and (c) with the teacher. Also, boys are currently behind their sisters in high-school and college graduation rates. Supporters say splitting students by gender minimizes distractions, helps them learn better and allows boys and girls to explore subjects they may not otherwise take. . In the first year of Foley, Alabama’s single-gender program, a third of the kids enrolled. The next year, two-thirds signed up, and in its third year 87 percent of parents requested the program. Principal Mansell reports that her single-gender classes produce fewer discipline problems, more parental support and better scores in writing, reading and math.

Single gender schools are rapidly growing in popularity

I believe this is also true because I found that in the early 1990’s there were only 2 single gender schools, nowadays there are 49 schools, and 65 percent have opened within the past three years. There are lots of cities that have already made the leap toward single-gender schools. The change could mean a boom in public schools splitting the genders. Leonard Sax, executive director of the National Association for Single gender Public Education, predicts that if public schools follow the path of private schools, where 7% are single gender, some 5,000 single-gender schools could open in the next 20 years. And Milwaukee would join several other large cities where public schools already offer single-gender classes. They include New York City — where there are nine single-gender public schools — as well as Chicago, Dallas, Seattle and Washington, D.C. Among advocates of single-gender public education, there are two camps: those who favor separating boys from girls because they are essentially different and those who favor separating boys from girls because they have different social experiences and social needs.

Let’s review the facts

  1. Distractions are a big problem in co-ed (multiple gender) classrooms.
  2. Guys think differently than Girls, enough said. And lastly..
  3. Single gender schools are rapidly growing in popularity because in the early ‘90s, there were 2 single gender schools, now there are 49.

Editor: This is a very interesting article. What do our Youngziners think -- separate schools or mixed?

 
nickm2   1 year ago

Mixed

Raptorman2012   1 year ago

Nice :D

katieb   1 year ago

Great job!!

Solmitz   1 year ago

Nice Article

allisonr   1 year ago

It is better to have mixed classes than seperate ones because when you are out of school, and you a job, and so on, boys and girls aren't seperated. So, if you were in seperate classes, boys and girls wouldn't know how to react and communicate with each other. But, from an academic point of view, seperate gender classes are a great idea! Your article was very persuasive Stephen! It was so cool being able to hear it again! AWESOME!

Tootifruit   1 year ago

i think classes should be mixed because at my school,Arrows Academy, sometimes i like to race with the boys.

i'm 11! and i'm homeschooled!!

hibaa   1 year ago

I think that boys and girls shouldent be separeted because i have friends that are boys since kindergarden. Its fun playing with them because i have friends that are girls who play with Friends that are boys. Plus there are some girls who just dont get along with other girls so they just play with boys. It wouldent be fair for them to be sitting alone because that person doesnt get along with girls.

lupitar   1 year ago

i agree.

leahg2   1 year ago

Cool!

sheelar   1 year ago

That would be great for 3rd, 4th, 5th and maybe sixth grade. Kindergarteners all are wild and energetic and same with 1st and maybe 2nd. Also this may cost more.

maryd   1 year ago

I totally disagree!Mixed classrooms you can learn about their gender and what they are doing outside of school life.(p.s i'm not afraid of snakes)

katieb   1 year ago

Oh, no!!!!! my comment wasn't posted!!! Did i say something bad?

Editor   1 year ago

katieb: We did not see your comment come through in this article. Matter of fact, we have been seeing very astute comments from children to this stimulating article and have been approving all of them. Can you please repost your comment.

The only comments we delete are those that have offensive language or are inappropriate personal remarks.

jessical   1 year ago

I LOVED your article Stephen!!! EXCELLENT!!! I understand what you are are thinking but, I would say that mixed gender schools are better just because you get to understand both boy and girl genders instead of just getting use to your own!!! But your article was persuasive!!!

riyac   1 year ago

Good job really good article i really do not know what else to say

colea   1 year ago

great article stephen you're in my class and your a genius!!!!!!

bryceb2   1 year ago

umm i already said he is a genius...

rileym   1 year ago

Great job Stephen!!!! I agree with you!!!!!!!!!:)

Armaan   1 year ago

I believe to get ready for the real world, we need to be in mixed classrooms. It creates competitiveness between the boys and the girls too. Obviously some would want single gender classes, but I don't like the idea.

cm   1 year ago

I think classes should be mixed

katiep   1 year ago

i think it might be a better idea to have single gender classes because girls understand each other and boys understand boys but they are taking away precious life skills so they should probably have a life skills class where boys and girls are both in it but the rest are single gender.

riyac   1 year ago

That is awsome stephan!! You are so right that mixed genders, there better mixed!

p.s He is in my class! Riya C

diamond   1 year ago

I think that there should be a mix for some subjects but others should be separate classes.

bryceb2   1 year ago

stephen is in my class and he is a genius!

hannahw   1 year ago

i think it is good to have a mixed class

dolphingirl   1 year ago

But sometimes a mix is more fun

adella   1 year ago

I think that the boys and girls need to be split up.
I shouldn't really have a say though because I'm homeshooled.

garden girl   1 year ago

I'm homeschooled too!!!

marian winslow   1 year ago

I'm homeschooled too! i think that for some core classes such as math and history, boys and girls should be split up, otherwise not.

dolphingirl   1 year ago

I agree

Clara Roberts   1 year ago

Nice essay! How old are you?

stephenl   1 year ago

Thanks, Bryce, but like the Article said at the top, I'm only 11.

Clara Roberts   1 year ago

I am eleven too! Are you home schooled?

bryceb2   1 year ago

11

7 + 1 =